3b - Traditional "slow birth," early understanding
William Harvey (1578-1657), through dissection of cold- and warm-blooded animals, described circulation of blood by the pumping action of the heart [1, 2]. He concluded:
"It is absolutely necessary to conclude that the blood is in a state of ceaseless motion; that this the act or function which the heart performs by means of its pulse; and that is the sole and only end of the motion and contraction of the heart."
This description predated the discovery of oxygen by more than a century [3]. In his investigations into the origins of life and fetal development, Harvey further pointed out the meaning and importance of pulsations of the umbilical cord:
"Moreover, it is a sure way to know whether the Infant that sticketh in the birth be alive, or not, by the pulsation of the Vmbilical Arteries. But most certain it is, that those Arteries are not moved by the virtue or operation of the Mothers, but of his own proper Heart: For they keep a distinct time and pawze, from the Mothers pulse: which is easily experimented, if you lay one hand upon the Mothers wrest, and the other on the Infants Navel-string. Nay in a Casarean Section, when the Embryo's have been yet involved in the membrane called Chorion, I have oftentimes found (even when the Mother was extinct, and stiffe almost with cold) the Vmbilical Arteries beating, and the Foetus himself lusty."
Jakob Rüff (1500-1558) of Zürich instructed midwives to cut the umbilical cord with clean scissors (Jch schneid das Nabelgerthli<n> des Kinds mit einem sauberen Scherlin auf 4 Zwerchfinger ab nahe beÿ dem Kind...) [4]. Rüff's work was translated and printed in English in 1637 [5]. The translation does not mention scissors, but after cutting the cord four fingers from the belly of the child, to then bind it with a double thread as near to the child's belly as possible. That there is no mention of bleeding suggests that waiting for pulsations in the cord to cease was implied.
Figure 2 is a drawing from Rüff's work, in which he also described the secundine (amniotic membranes and placenta) and its attachment to the womb "with veins and arteries, by which it attracts and draws blood for the nourishment of the fetus, being attracted to the infant by his navel," thus showing already in the sixteenth century (a century before Harvey) some understanding of the function of blood. This knowledge was in part handed down from texts dating back to ancient Greece [2].
Harvey, William. Anatomical exercitations concerning the generation of living creatures to which are added particular discourses of births and of conceptions, &c.London : Printed by James Young, for Octavian Pulleyn, and are to be sold at his shop at the sign of the Rose in St. Pauls Church-yard, 1653. From Early English Books Online, http://eebo.chadwyck.com/
Khan IA, Daya SK, Gowda RM. Evolution of the theory of circulation. Int J Cardiol. 2005 Feb 28; 98(3):519-21. (Abstract in PubMed)
Rüff, Jakob. The expert midwife, or An excellent and most necessary treatise of the generation and birth of man Wherein is contained many very notable and necessary particulars requisite to be knovvne and practised: with diuers apt and usefull figures appropriated to this worke. Also the causes, signes, and various cures, of the most principall maladies and infirmities incident to women. Six bookes compiled in Latine by the industry of Iames Rueff, a learned and expert chirurgion: and now translated into English for the generall good and benefit of this nation. London : Printed by E. G[riffin] for S. B[urton] and are to be sold by Thomas Alchorn at the signe of the Greene Dragon in Saint Pauls church-yard, 1637. From Early English Books Online at http://eebo.chadwyck.com/PDF file pages: pp78-79, pp80-81, pp82-83.
-- Early English Books Online (EEBO) contains digital facsimile page images of virtually every work printed in England, Ireland, Scotland, Wales and British North America and works in English printed elsewhere from 1473-1700.
Harvey, William (1653) Anatomical exercitations concerning the generation of living creatures to which are added particular discourses of births and of conceptions, &c.
Khan IA et al. (2005) Evolution of the theory of circulation.
Harken AH (1976) Oxygen, politics and the American Revolution (with a note on the bicentennial of phlogiston).
Keller HE. Jakob Ruf, ein Zürcher Stadtchirurg und Theatermacher im 16. Jahrhundert.